Member since 2011/07/03

Where you wish you were
Reading/watching porn, masturbating ;P


No story posted

Favorites of MissNutterbutter

Title Genre Read Rating Themes
I lost my virginity to my sister. True Story 672192 times. 78.5 % First Time, Incest, Male / Female Teens, Masturbation, Virginity
The Farmer's Little Daughter Fiction 676224 times. 91.6 % Exhibitionism, First Time, Incest, Male/Teen Female, Oral Sex, Spanking, Virginity
My Amazing First Time Fantasy 107598 times. 93.2 % Anal, Ass to mouth, Blowjob, Cum Swallowing, First Time, Gay, Oral Sex, Teen, Teen Male Solo, Virginity
Rest Stop Quickie Fiction 34014 times. 92.5 % Consensual Sex, Teen Male/Teen Female, Virginity, Water Sports/Pissing
golden showers at boarding school Fiction 66933 times. 91.9 % School, Teen Female/Teen Female, Water Sports/Pissing
Cameron & Alex (Second Installment) Fantasy 15381 times. 83.3 % Anal, Ass to mouth, Boy, Boy / Boy, Coercion, Cum Swallowing, First Time, Gay, Incest, Masturbation, Oral Sex, Threesome, Virginity, Water Sports/Pissing, Young
Beach House Sleepover Dark Fantasy 426411 times. 94.2 % Anal, Bi-sexual, Blowjob, Boy / Boy, Cum Swallowing, Gay, Oral Sex, Teen Male / Teen Male
do me a favor? True Story 182106 times. 95 % Anal, Ass to mouth, Blowjob, Gay
My first time. True Story 88854 times. 93.5 % First Time, Masturbation, Oral Sex, Water Sports/Pissing, Young
Brother Fucker - 1 Fiction 213279 times. 94.5 % Blowjob, Cum Swallowing, Gay, Incest, Masturbation, Teen Male / Teen Male
Brother Fucker - 2 Fiction 203046 times. 94.7 % Anal, Blowjob, Cum Swallowing, Gay, Incest, Teen Male / Teen Male, Virginity
Little Sister's Dilemma Fiction 350328 times. 95.8 % Consensual Sex, First Time, Teen Female/Teen Female, Virginity
Beach House Sleepover 2 Dark Fantasy 54510 times. 93.2 % Anal, Ass to mouth, Bi-sexual, Blowjob, Boy / Boy, Gay, Hardcore, Teen Male / Teen Male
What happens under the covers...stays under the covers... Fiction 212526 times. 95 % Blowjob, Cum Swallowing, First Time, Incest, Male / Female Teens, Masturbation, Oral Sex, Romance, Virginity, Young
Swinging in the Neighborhood True Story 197889 times. 95.8 % First Time, Oral Sex, Teen Male/Teen Female, Water Sports/Pissing
When I Was A Young Boy - PART 4! True Story 27564 times. 83.9 % Blowjob, Boy / Boy, Cum Swallowing, Incest, Violence, Young
Hot Tub Sister Fiction 190290 times. 93.7 % Anal, First Time, Incest, Teen Male/Teen Female
My Cousin, Beth Fantasy 510465 times. 95.8 % Consensual Sex, Incest, Romance, Teen Male/Teen Female, Young
Not According to Plan Fiction 138408 times. 95.6 % Consensual Sex, Incest, Masturbation, Oral Sex, Romance, Voyeurism
Helping out a new friend Fiction 47223 times. 94 % Anal, Blowjob, Consensual Sex, Cum Swallowing, First Time, Oral Sex, Romance, Teen Male/Teen Female, Virginity
Robbie & Eve - I'm right here if you want me True Story 58503 times. 94.9 % Consensual Sex
LAURA: A Girl'’s Story Fiction 163233 times. 92 % Consensual Sex, First Time, Incest, Teen Male / Female, Virginity