A part of me was a little nervous that Michelle would feel bad about what we did in the closet and tell someone. I was half waiting for her uncles to come kick the shit out of me. But at dinner time she just had this grin on her face every time she looked at me. She had the most beautiful smile and I wanted to just take her upstairs and play with her all night.
I was hoping Michelle was curious enough to want more, I could tell I made her feel really good. I just had to find a way to be with her alone without raising any suspicion. After all, there's really no good reason for us to be alone together. I decided I would try sneaking into her room at night and hope she doesn't scream bloody murder.
Later that night around 12am, after my wife was fast asleep, I quietly snuck out of bed and into the bathroom. I turned the light on and locked the door into our room so it appeared I was on the toilet. I slowly opened Michelle's bathroom door into her room and to my surprise, she was still up.
She was snuggled up in her bed with her lamp on reading a book.
"it's about time!" she whispered.
"I'm sorry, I wasn't sure if you'd still be up." I replied.
"are you kidding? After doing that in the closet earlier, I could barely wait for tonight to come, I'm glad you read my mind! I didn't know you could make me feel so good down there!" she exclaimed.
"I can make you feel really good down there, Michelle, we just have to keep this our little secret." I whispered.
"I know," she replied, "I'm too young to be doing these things with boys. And if my dad knew what you did to me in the closet today, he'd be so mad!"
"do you want me to make you feel good again? You'll have to be quiet so we don't wake anyone up." I said.
"oh, yes please. I will be quiet, do you want to touch me again?" she asked.
I pulled her covers down to the foot of the bed, exposing her young teen body. She was wearing a loose tank-top without a bra so I could see her little nipples poking through. She also wore tight white cotton panties, so thin I could see her little slit showing a little.
I leaned down and kissed her inner thigh, slowly going higher, kissing her legs softly until I got to her panties. I gently moved both of Michelle's legs to the side, giving me more access between her legs. I kissed her small mound over her thin panties and I could already taste her wet juices soaking through, she was enjoying this as much as I was.
"oh, yes, that feels so good keep going, oh yes!" cried Michelle.
She quietly moaned and pulled my head closer to her as I found her sensitive spot and massaged it. I knew that because Michelle was a virgin and only being 14, I had to take things slow and get her ready for me to break her hymen.
I was finally ready to see what her treasure looked like under those thin panties. Because it was so dark in the closet earlier, I never got to see what she looked like.
I moved her panties aside, enough to see her innocent folds of skin, guarding her delicate virgin hole. I gently spread her lips apart with my thumbs to expose her sweet pussy.
I had never seen anything so tight before. Looking at her little hole covered by her hymen, which separated me from her innocence, I wasn't sure I'd be able to penetrate her. But I had gone too far, risked too much to go this far. I wasn't going to give up now.
She moaned as I stuck my tongue inside her folds, going up and down her slit, from the top of her clit down to her 14 year old vagina. There was so much I wanted to do with her but all I could do was make her feel good and want more.
I started licking and sucking on her clit faster and faster as she started to breathe faster and faster. I decided she was ready for me to start with one finger. I rubbed my right index finger along the inside of her mound to get it wet, and slowly put it at the entrance to her innocence.
"mhm, yes!" exclaimed Michelle, as I continued to pleasure her sensitive button.
I gently inserted my finger into Michelle's tight teen pussy, at first she instinctively clenched as my finger slowly made it's way inside her. She whimpered in pain as my finger fully penetrated her.
"are you ok, sweetie?"
"yes, I'm fine, it just hurt a little. It's just so small! I knew I wasn't ready to have sex!" she cried.
"it's ok, it just needs to be stretched out a little. It's going to hurt a little, but I'll make sure you feel good." I assured her.
With one finger already inside her, but her hymen not fully broken, I knew she wasn't ready yet. I moved my finger around stretching her vagina walls more and more. A little blood leaked out and on my finger, she's getting closer.
"ugh, it hurts but feels so good!" sighed Michelle.
I quickly, but quietly, got the lube from our bathroom, and applied it to 2 of my fingers. I gently inserted them into the entrance of her violated teen pussy. Slowly they went deeper and deeper inside her, until both fingers were all the way inside her vagina.
I took off my clothes and pulled down Michelle's white panties, laid on my back, and helped Michelle get on top of me so she was sitting on top of my about ready to explode cock.
I got out a bit of lube and massaged it around her hole and put some on my penis. I held her slender waist with my hands and slowly rocked her back and forth massaging her mound with my penis.
"ohh, that feels so good, I can't stand it anymore! I just want to have sex with you!" cried Michelle, as she started shaking with pleasure.
I rocked her back and forth on my penis for a minute getting her ready for the inevitable plunge. I had Michelle put her weight on her feet so I could position my penis in the entrance to her tight virgin pussy.
I massaged my penis on her, put the tip in her entrance, grabbed hold of her slender waist and pushed her body down towards me.
In one swift motion her young teen body fell down against me. Michelle had to cover her mouth to muffle her cry of pain as my cock tore it's way deep inside her. Blood leaked out and dripped on me and her innocent pink bed sheets.
I held her slender waist and helped lift Michelle up till only the tip of my penis was inside her pussy, and then slowly lowered her back down. It went in easier this time and she sighed in relief that the worst was over.
"ohh that hurt really bad, but it feels better now", sighed Michelle as she wiped away a few tears from her eyes.
I gently picked her up in my arms and laid her on her back. I kissed her lips and told her how beautiful she was. I then realized I was so caught up with taking her virginity that I completely forgot to get her entirely naked.
I pulled up her tank top over her head, freeing her 14 year old petite tits. As I knelt over her I realized how beautiful she really was, even at 14. There was hardly a blemish on her. She was as close to perfection as you could get. And she was mine.
I laid down on her kissing her neck as I inserted my erect penis back inside her warm, and wet deflowered pussy. It wasn't nearly as tight, but tight enough where it made me feel unbelievable!
It was hard not shooting my load into Michelle as I penetrated her, deeper until all of me was inside of her. Then back out till the tip was the only thing inside, and then back in all the way. In and out, faster and faster.
Michelle wrapped her legs around me, pulling me in closer as she let out muffled moans of pleasure.
"oh it feels so good, keep going! Faster, deeper inside me!" sighed Michelle, as she started to tremble in delight.
If I could just keep this up for a few more minutes, I knew I could help Michelle experience her first orgasm.
Her breathing got louder and faster, and her pussy kept getting wetter and wetter as I kept thrusting in and out of her.
I tried clearing my mind, trying desperately to delay the inevitable explosion that was building. But I couldn't stop thinking about the fact I was making love to this beautiful 14 year old girl who I had been obsessing about for over 2 years. All the pictures I saw where I fantasized about being with her was actually happening!
I couldn't contain myself any longer, I picked her up and knelt on the bed holding her tight petite ass as I helped her slide up and down.
Just as I was about to explode, Michelle started shaking uncontrollably and moaning as quiet as she could. I could feel her pussy throbbing around my thick rod deep inside her and I knew she was having her first orgasm.
With the thought that I had given my dream girl her first orgasm, I blew my long awaited load inside her. To this day, I have never had a better orgasm than this one. After multiple warm gobs of cum were shot deep inside her, I laid her down on the bed and rested on top of her, leaving my penis happily inside. I could feel both of us throbbing in pleasure.
"that...was...amazing", she sighed between quick shallow breaths.
It was only then I came to realize the seriousness of what we had just done. The thought of getting her pregnant wasn't even considered until after I shot my huge load inside Michelle's womb.
"you haven't gotten your period yet, have you?" I asked, hopefully.
"I actually got it when I turned 13...oh..." replied Michelle as she realized why I asked.
"and you're not on birth control, by chance, are you?"
"no, honestly I didn't think I'd be having sex this young, not that I regret it. This was definitely the most fun I've ever had." exclaimed Michelle.
"me too! But we won't know for a while, let's not worry about it." I replied confidently.
I never would have admitted it, but a part of me wished I got this perfect angel pregnant so I could share something with her forever. But the more logical side of me realized that would ultimately get me a 15 year bid in the state prison. I didn't care about that, I would do it again in a heart beat. And do it again, we did. But not that night.
I got tissues and gently cleaned her up, tucked her into bed, and kissed her goodnight, turning off the lights on my way out.