These stories all came from my life and experiences. Almost.
This story, as are all the stories in this series, is almost true. This is how it really happened. Almost.
When May got home from practice the following night, the chores in the horse barns were already done. April was sitting on the top rail of the indoor coral watching a couple of 4-H’ers put their ponies through their paces. I was standing inside the ring leaning against the fence near here. Every time I looked up into those emerald eyes I wanted to pull her down off the rail and kiss her. But watching how she had moved so gingerly around the barn, clearly sore from our lovemaking the night before, I didn’t want to rush her back into something that would cause her to regret it. So I just imagined those bright red lips ringing my cock, feeling my cockhead deep in her throat. I was lost in my daydream when May snuck up behind me and put her hands over my eyes and said “Guess Who!” I had almost forgotten her declaration the night before when she revealed she had watched April and I during April’s first sexual experience.
“Are you ready to take me up in the hay loft and make me into a woman, David?” I turned and leaned over the top rail of the corral.
“May, I don’t think it’s a good idea. You are still too young.” I was trying to talk her out of it. Taking April’s virginity was one thing, but taking May’s made me feel like too much of a dirty old man. “Why don’t you wait until someone special comes along?”
“That’s not fair! April is only fifteen months older than I am! If you are special enough for her, why aren’t you special enough for me? Is she that much prettier than I am?” I could tell there was genuine hurt in her eyes.
“No, not at all. You are very pretty and very sexy. It runs in your jeans. I am honored that you want me to be your first, but really, do you want your first sexual experience to be the same as your sisters?” She thought about it and then slowly shook her head no.
“No.” She dropped her eyes. “I guess not.” She looked up at both of us. “But you two made it look like so much fun. I just wanted to have a turn.”
“Don’t worry. Your turn will come soon enough,” April reassured her younger sister. “Why don’t you go in and get a shower. There’s a chicken in the oven and we will eat in about twenty minutes.” May turned and walked out of the barn.
“You know, David, I don’t mind sharing. Last night was really fantastic. I wouldn’t mind at all if you were May’s first. She should lose her virginity to someone who will treat her right, not some young cowboy who thinks eight seconds is a good ride.” We both laughed at her joke. “Besides, I’m still too sore to have another go at you tonight.”
“You are SO bad!” I said laughing. “What have I created?”
“A woman. A red-headed, green eyed, hot blooded, horny WOMAN!” She shouted the last word and the ring riders turned to see if April was speaking to them. “Girls, when you are done, be sure to put your horses on half a bucket of grain and fresh water. Last one out shut off the ring lights please.”
“Yes Ma’am” they all chirped. Only a few years older than they were, the riders all looked up to April as a wise old rider. April had one several competitions throughout Oregon and the northwest. They all wanted to ride like her. I just wanted to ride her. I offered her my arm and she used it to dismount the rail into the ring. We walked together to the gate at the end of the ring nearest the house, our boots kicking up the smell of dirt and horse manure and cedar chips as we walked.
When we got into the house, it smelled fantastic. April’s mother can’t cook a lick, but April sure could. That roasting chicken smelled great. I could hear the sound of the shower running down the hall, which meant May had left the door to her bedroom open. I poured three glasses of iced water and set them at the supper table. While May finished the dinner preparation, I got the table service out of the dishwasher and set the table.
“David! Can you come here? There’s something wrong with the drain again.” May called from down the hallway.
“Are you decent?”
“Yes. Hurry, the water won’t go down.”
I walked down the hall and stopped in the front bathroom for the plunger. May was decent, but just barely. She wore a towel wrapped around her head and another around her torso. She was still glistening with droplets, so I knew she was nude under the towel.
“You get dressed and I will get the clog out, “ I said as I entered her bathroom nearly closed the door behind me, leaving only a crack. But when I looked into the shower drain, it was dry. I turned on the water to see how badly it was clogged and the water never backed up. It was a set-up.
“There’s nothing wrong with the drain, May.” I opened the door and she was lying on her bed, naked as the day she was born. Still damp from her shower, she lay on her side facing me with one leg up, creating a figure four with her legs. Her fifteen year old pussy only had a smattering of short blonde hairs. Her small breasts jutted out from her athletic frame. She had a six-pack hard stomach and thighs to match. The lips of her pussy were already engorged. Clearly she was aroused. I could see the tip of her clit poking out at the top of her delicate labia.
“May, you are so beautiful. I can’t do this.” I turned and exited the room. Safely in the hallway, I turned back, “Dinner is ready. Get dressed and come on.” To her credit, the thought of food stopped her from feeling rejected or sorry for herself. I hadn’t made it all the way to the kitchen when she bound out of her room and down the hallway in just a pink t-shirt and pale green shorts. We ate and laughed and no one brought up the fact that I had seen both girls naked and had fucked one of them. We cleaned up from dinner and then headed downstairs to the family room to watch an old movie.
I sat in the middle of the couch with one sister on each side of me. During commercials we’d take turns tickling each other and then when the movie came back on, we’d just cuddle together, my arm draped around each girl. We started with their heads on my shoulder and my arms around their back. Then after one commercial, April shifted her position to lean back into me and put her feet up on the arm of the couch. This allowed my hand to drape across her midsection, just beneath her breasts. I stroked her belly and began to fondle the underside of her breasts. She sighed and sank deeper into me, giving me the green light to continue to explore her breasts and stomach. When the next commercial came on, it was back to tickling and wrestling. May noticed how April was sitting and when the commercials ended, she assumed the mirror image of her sister on the right side of my body. Now my hands were draped across two beautiful young women. I continued to fondle and stroke April with my left hand while I kept my right hand still. May adjusted her seat until my hand was pressed against the underside of her breast. I got the hint. I began to softly caress the bottom of her breast and her taught stomach. She too sighed with satisfaction. As I cupped the full breast of April in my left hand, I rubbed the belly of young May, slowly moving the fabric of her t-shirt upward, exposing her stomach to my fingers. I traced lazy circles across the ridges of her stomach muscles. I took the liberty of looking down. I noticed that May had an indentation in where her hip bone jutted out farther than her stomach, raising her waistband away from her skin. That dark triangle beckoned for my hand to explore. And so I did. Slowly and inexorably I let my fingers explore until the tips of my fingers were under her waistband and traveling along the crease of her hip and stomach. She did not object.
I pinched and punished the hard nipple in my left hand, causing April to squirm and shift. But my right hand continued to explore slowly and deliberately. I pressed deeper into the area under her shorts until my fingertips grazed those short blonde pussy hairs. I felt the hair there and my cock stirred. Each of the girls had one hand tucked between their body and mine and their free hands were resting on my thighs.
The tip of my middle finger lightly grazed the skin protecting her engorged clit and May bucked. I slowly withdrew my hand and slid it upward along her stomach and under her shirt. I felt her hard nipples on her small breasts. I lightly scraped them with the palm of my hand and May arched her back to press her nipples harder into my hand. I dropped my both of my hands to their midsections and stopped all caresses. When I did that, both of them started lightly scratching my legs. Just then a commercial broke into the movie and we were off to the races. Everyone was tickling everyone and things were quickly getting out of hand. I felt a small hand grip my hard cock through my jeans. I had both of April’s hands in one of mine, that left May as the culprit. I turned my face toward hers and she was looking at me with a “Well, what are you going to do about it?” look.
“It’s time for bed girls. Long day tomorrow.”
“Come tuck me in and kiss me goodnight,” pleaded April.
“Sure. Go get ready for bed and holler down when you want me to come tuck you in.” She got up from the couch and bounced upstairs to change clothes, brush her hair and teeth. May stayed beside me.
“You too May,” I told her.
“I want you to tuck me in too.”
“Yes, I promise.” She skipped up the stairs two at a time.
I turned off the television and the lights and followed. I walked down the hall, softly knocked on April’s door and walked in. She lay on her bed, covers back, wearing only panties and a spaghetti strap white camisole. Her red hair was splayed out on the pillow and the soft light from the lamp on her nightstand cast a warm glow. I knelt down next to the bed, leaned in and kissed her softly on the lips. I pulled up her camisole and softly kissed the entire globe of each luscious breast. Then I pulled her panties down and kissed her mound, taking the time to breathe deeply of her sexual scent.
“Good night, Princess April. Sweet dreams.”
“Good night David. I will dream of you tonight.” I smiled and kissed her again before standing up and leaving the room.
I closed her door behind me and walked down the hall to her sister’s room. I knocked softly and let myself in. May was laying on the bed as the blonde version of her older sister. She had both arms over her head, forearms pressed together. This brought her tiny breasts higher, and I could see the harden nipples straining against her t-shirt. I leaned in to kiss her on the forehead and she tilted her head back, seeking my lips with hers. I obliged, giving her a soft and gentle kiss. Her arms locked around my neck and I could feel her hunger rising with her passion. I responded with more pressure, parting her lips with my tongue and teaching her how to French kiss. My left hand, knowing a ripe opportunity when it sees one, took advantage of the situation by exploring her breasts and stomach. Just the sensation of those hard stomach muscles caused my cock to stir. May is so athletic and sexy.
We continued to kiss for the longest time. Every time I made a move to break it off, May pulled tighter. I responded by cupping her pussy through her shorts. She was hot and damp, plainly aroused by her hormones and her fantasy. I rubbed her pussy, feeling the fabric yield as I pressed it between her erect pussy lips. She moaned into my mouth. The legs of her shorts were loose enough to allow my fingers to press them aside and touch her pussy directly. She was so slick from her own juices that my fingers slid up and down her slit easily. Each time my fingers touched her clit she jumped as if shocked with electricity. I finally had to reach up and loosen her grip with both hands.
“I need to breathe!” I said. “You don’t have to hold on so tight. I am not going anywhere.” She blushed and turned her face. “But you are going to have to lie there while I eat you.” Her eyes got big. I kissed her mouth, her neck, her exposed breasts. I could fit her entire breast in my mouth and tease the nipple with my tongue. Then I kissed her stomach for a long time, licking and nibbling every gorgeous square inch. I hooked my thumbs into her shorts and began to tug them down.
“Raise your hips.” She complied and I slipped her short off. Now she only wore a t-shirt gathered around her neck. I moved down to the foot of her bed, hooked her thighs with my hands, and pulled her exposed pussy down to my face. I dove right in, skipping any additional formalities. I have always been hyper attracted to stiff labia that protrude like flower petals from a woman’s cunt. May’s labia were perfect in every respect. I sucked and licked at them until they were deep purple from all the blood trapped in them. Her clit was stiff and protruding nearly a quarter of an inch. As I ate her pussy, I would let a lip or tongue graze against her clit, causing her to gush additional fluid. Her secretions were delicious and sweet. I lapped at her slit until I could feel her stiffen. She bucked and lunged, moaning and gasping. She allowed the waves of pleasure to wash over her again and again. Finally she pushed at my head, desperate to keep me away while she recovered from her very first orgasm. Her pussy was hyper sensitive.
I climbed onto the bed beside her.
“Mmmmmmmmm. No. I want to feel what it’s like when you are on top of me. When you are inside of me. Can we do that before you leave? Please?” She asked so sweetly, I couldn’t refuse.
“I’ll do it, but first you need to do for me what I just did for you.”
“You want me to lick your thing?”
“No, I want you to put it in your mouth. I need you to suck it until it’s good and wet, so it doesn’t hurt you.”
“Ok.” She popped right up, pulled her t-shirt off over the top of her head. She tugged at my jeans until the button came undone and tried to pull them off without unzipping them.
“Here, allow me.” I stood up, dropped my pants to the floor, and kicked off my boots while my pant legs were still on them. I loosened the buttons on my shirt and pulled it off. My cock waved in the breeze and May giggled at the sight of it flopping around. I knelt next to the bed, pulled her head over to my cock and slipped it between her lips. May was a natural born cocksucker. Her first instinct was to deep throat my member. It was such a pleasant surprise, I nearly blasted her tonsils for the first stroke.
“Wow! You are fantastic!”
“Thwanks!” she replied, a mouth full of cock slowing her enunciation. She bobbed up and down, keeping my cock deep in her throat, breathing in and out through her nose when she was on the upstroke. I slipped my fingers into her blonde hair and pulled her down even farther on my shaft, until I could feel her nose against my stomach. She didn’t gag or sputter, she just kept sucking cock. I couldn’t take it anymore. I withdrew my cock from her mouth and rolled her on her back. I climbed over the top of her and she spread her legs wide. I kissed her and lowered my body until I could feel my shaft lying on top of her cunt. I pulled back and the head slipped down her crevice. I pressed forward and it parted her pussy lips. I could feel it seeking the opening to her cunt. She adjusted her hips, using her ankles on my ass for leverage.
“Now!” she commanded when she felt everything was perfectly aligned. I thrust into her and buried three inches against her intact maidenhead. She responded with a cry of pleasure. I pulled back an inch and thrust again, tearing her hymen with my cock. She tensed and froze. So did I. When I felt her relax and breathe again, I started timing my thrusts to her inhalations. I kissed her and began to thrust faster and faster. Her pussy was so tight around my cock. It throbbed and milked my shaft. I loved the feeling of her pussy around my manhood. I could feel my orgasm building. May sensed it too. She tightened her grip around my waste and began to spur me on. I was fucking her with abandon, bed thumping, springs screeching. She was moaning, I was moaning, and then we both came together in wave after steaming wave of love juices. I buried my cock against her cervix and pushed four heavy spurts of cum into her baby chamber. Spent and sweating, I collapsed on top of her, breathing heavy and smiling from ear to ear.
“You were amazing, May. Simply amazing!” She beamed at the compliment. “Was it everything you wanted? Everything you hoped for?”
“It was so much better! I never thought it could feel so good. I never want it to end. Can we do it again? Right now?”
“No May. I can’t go again right now. And with your parents coming home, I don’t know if we will ever get a chance to do it again.” I rolled over to the side and pulled her on top of me, keeping my erection locked into her cunt.
“Yes we will. I am sure of it.” She pulled off of my dick and spun around, so she could take it in her mouth again. As she cleaned our cum off my cock, I dove into her freshly fucked quim. For the first time in my life I ate my own cum out of a woman. As I was eating her, I couldn’t help but notice the cute little pucker of her rosebud. Just to be funny, I licked her ass, tickling her rosebud with my tongue. She responded by pressing her ass against my face. I was shocked. I probed her ass with my tongue and she responded by burying my cock into her throat.
Now I was hard again. This time I would last a long time. “If you want to have sex again, I have to warn you that I will take a long time to cum. If you are sore now, you will be really sore tomorrow. Too sore to sit, too sore to play basketball. Too sore to ride horses.”
“Ok, I get it,” she giggled. “We can wait until after the game tomorrow night to have sex again. If I score 30 points, can we have sex again?”