Here is part 3! Sorry it took me so long to get it out, but alas, life has been busy for me. Let me know what you think and I will keep them coming.
There we were, Mandy, Beth, and I in the bathroom. I still couldn't really believe what just happened, Beth had just agreed to fuck me, with Mandy watching no less. I have no idea what I did to deserve this but I was not about to complain about it now. My only reservation about this whole situation was this; Beth was my half sister. While she didn't know it, I did, and beyond the obvious moral questions of incest, I wanted her to be aware of the situation before agreeing to something like this. Mandy I had no problem with, Michael, my dad, was her step father, and we weren't related, so fair game for me!
Beth on the other hand, sweet Beth. It could be because I only met her today, but that bond that I can only guess is felt between brothers and sisters after years of living together, I certainly didn't feel it. I know Beth didn't feel it, seeing as how she wanted me to fuck her. My reservations about Beth were quickly dwindling, partly I'm sure, when she stood up in front of me and stepped in close in front of me.
My heart was pounding in my chest as she stood right in front of me. Her heaving breasts were just barely touching me. She took my hands and brought them up to the back of her neck, then reached behind her back. I slowly found the knot and pulled the strings apart, letting her top fall down to the ground.
Her breasts were perfectly rounded, and tanned the same slightly bronzed tone as the rest of her skin. Her nipples were fully erect as I traced my hand lightly down her neck and let my fingers trace around her areola. I felt her shudder as my finger rubbed back and forth on her hard nipple.
I looked up and realized that she was staring into my eyes, a look of pure vulnerability. I leaned in and kissed her, softly at first, allowing myself to taste her supple lips. I pulled back a fraction of an inch, paused to look into her eyes, and when she gave me a smile I went all out. We started making out passionately. I let her wrap her arms around my neck and when I moved my hands down her back they cupped her round ass, and lifted her up off of the ground.
She seemed to be expecting this and let me lift her, wrapping her legs around me to get a better grip on my torso. I walked her into the bedroom and gently laid her down onto the bed. Mandy followed behind us and sat down at the head of the bed. She was silently eyeing the two of us like a cat eyeing a mouse.
This was an entirely different experience than the one I just had with Mandy. With Mandy I felt an animalistic lust that only seemed to be matched by her sexual appetite. With Beth however, it was a tender experience, I could feel her innocence and just in the same way I could sense Mandy's sexual libido. I could easily tell Beth required a softer hand, a gentler touch would get the results I wanted.
I gently placed kisses all over her body, starting at her lips, moving down her neck, and down her shoulder. She started breathing heavier and letting out soft moans of pleasure as I moved towards the top of her breasts and down to her now fully erect nipples. I rolled her tits between my teeth and heard her gasp.
I couldn't wait anymore, I stood up and started to pull off her bikini bottom, she lifted her hips up to make it
easier. Once they were off she spread her legs, inviting me to take her.
"Are you sure about this?" I asked her. I hoped that asking that wasn't going to bite me in the ass, but it
seemed like the right thing to do.
To my relief she nodded her head yes. "I'm ready. Just go slow."
I got on top of her, lining up my cock with her tight slit and slowly began to press my head against her opening. I slowly began pushing, relishing in how tight she was. Beth had her eyes closed and her mouth opened. As I went in deeper and deeper she held her breath, she barely moved as I stretched out her canal with my throbbing cock.
After a few minutes I was three quarters of the way inside of her when I could barely squeeze in any more. I started slowly sliding out, and Beth began to moan in pleasure as I withdrew my meat from her tight pussy. Looking down I could see her lips clinging to me as kept pulling out.
I pulled out all the way to the base of my head before pushing back in, this time a little faster. I could feel
Beth getting wetter and wetter by the second, as this time it was much easier to push in, and I also got a bit deeper inside of her. By the third push in I had bottomed out, my balls resting comfortably against her asshole.
Now that she was lubed up and starting to stretch out a little, I began picking up the pace. I was still being careful not to go too hard, but I didn't stop as I moved in and out. Beth began moaning louder, her hips gyrating to the rhythm of my thrusts.
"Faster." she whispered hoarsely. I picked up the pace and she immediately got even wetter. "Oh yes, keep going faster, do it harder."
Not needing a second invitation, I started to discard my caution and began thrusting into her now sopping wet pussy faster and harder. I began to really fuck her, and she seemed to be enjoying the hell out of herself.
"Oh fuck yes David! Fuck me! Fu- fu- fu- FUCK-MEEEE!" She screamed as she had her first orgasm. Her pussy clenched like a vice on my dick and I had to stop for a second. She threw her arms and legs around me and clamped her body up against mine while she had spasms all along her body. This lasted for a few seconds, her breathing coming in ragged gasps until she began to come down from her orgasm.
I heard another moan and looked up. I hadn't been paying attention to Mandy this entire time, but as soon as I saw her I kind of wished that I had. At some point she had taken off her shirt, and was now in just her thong. One of her hands was massaging her naked breasts, squeezing and pulling on her nipples, while the other was down her pants furiously rubbing and fingering her pussy with her eyes closed.
I couldn't believe this was happening, I was watching my step sister get off on me fucking my half sister right in front of her. This was making me even hotter, and I began thrusting again, all the while looking at
Mandy playing with herself. She opened her eyes and saw me watching her as I began fucking Beth, and the smile she gave me almost made me cum right there.
"How is she? She tight?" Mandy asked me.
"Like nothing I've ever had before, I love it." I said back. "Are you having fun watching?" At this she pulled her thong aside to let me see her pussy dripping with her own cum.
"You tell me, can you see my cum?" She put two fingers knuckle deep into her pussy and pulled them out and offered them over to me, globs of cum were on her fingers. I opened my mouth and sucked hard on her fingers until all of her tasty juices were in my mouth.
"Mmmm." She purred. "I think I'm kind of getting jealous of all this attention my little sister is getting. I think
I need another dose of you hard cock in me." She crawled over to Beth and I, and did something I never would have expected. She straddled Beth's face, pulled her thong aside, and sat her pussy right on Beth's face.
Beth, who was at this point still recovering from her orgasm, never knew what hit her. She let out a muffled squeal as Mandy's wet pussy hit her mouth. Mandy seemed to be getting off on this, she was sitting so she had Beth's arms pinned down with her legs, and with me still inside of her pinning down her hips, she couldn't move.
Mandy began to grind on Beth's face, rubbing her pussy back and forth on her face. She didn't seem to be getting the attention she desired because after a few gyrations she got an angry look on her face.
"Beth, I'm not getting up until I cum, so you better start using that tongue or I'll just sit here all day." She said with a stern voice. She sat still for a few more seconds before a huge grin came across her face.
I couldn't exactly see what was going on, but from Mandy's smile, she must have gotten her way. She started swirling her hips again, and I could see brief glimpses of Beth's tongue flicking over Mandy's clit.
All of this action was driving me over the edge, and seeing Beth eat out Mandy was driving me into animal fucking mode. Abandoning all caution to the wind, I began fucking Beth's tight little snatch as hard and as fast as I could. I could hear muffled moans coming from Beth, which in turn was making Mandy moan.
"Oh fuck Beth, you are so fucking tight! I'm gonna cum!" I began fucking her faster, jack hammering her tight little pussy, I could feel her juices flowing steadily now, dripping down my ball sack and along my legs. I could feel my balls getting tighter as Beth's pussy kept clenching on my cock as I pumped faster and faster. Beth let out a scream as my cum exploded deep inside of her.
Mandy let out a deep purr and got off of Beth's face, which was now covered in her juices. She was wearing a devilish grin as she looked down at Beth, who was still recovering from her multiple orgasms.
When she began to come to Mandy cupped a hand on the side of her face, and bent over next to her.
"Now we are even. You tell anyone about what you saw, and I will make sure they know about what you just did. Do we understand each other?" She whispered in her ear.
Beth's eyes were still closed as she nodded her head yes.
"Good. Now, I think it's my turn do finish what we started. David--." Mandy was interrupted by the chiming of her cell phone. She frowned when she looked at it. "Fuck, Mom wants us back at the house. She sent Dad out to find us, we need to head back. Come on Bethy, get dressed." We all got dressed and headed back up to the house.
The rest of the day was spent walking around the place. We went to a vineyard that Michael owned, took a tour, came back to the house and Angie cooked us dinner and ate outside. I had to admit, it was very nice.
The sun had set and we were all enjoying each other's company. Angie and the girls were talking about themselves, their hobbies, what they liked. I told them a little about myself, but for the most part I just let them talk. Michael was also very quiet throughout the night. He kept looking over at me, he looked like he wanted to say something but kept stopping himself. It was dark out, and we were all about to head inside when he finally spoke.
"I actually need to talk to you all about a couple of things while we're all here." He took a deep breath, and looked at Angie, then me. "Girls, I just want you all to know how much I love you all. The first thing is that David is going to be staying with us. He is moving in with us, I know this is going to be an adjustment, but I'm confident that we will be able to work out whatever issues come up." He looked around at the girls, who didn't say anything.
"There is also one more thing. And this is the big one. I'm sure you are all are wondering as to why David is going to be staying with us. Or who David is to me." He took a deep breath and was quiet for a few seconds. I think the only other person who seemed as uncomfortable as he did was me, seeing as I was the only one who knew what he was going to say. He looked across the table to me, and took another deep breath. "David is my son."
The girls were silent. Mandy and Beth both had their mouths open. I couldn't look either of them in the eye. We were all silent as Michael kept talking.
"I recently found out about David, his mother and I lived together a long time ago, long before I ever met your mother. We broke up and I never knew that she was pregnant until she contacted me a few months ago and told me about David. Unfortunately, she passed away right after and I had to track down where she was. I met David, and asked him to move in with us and he agreed. " He looked around at the girls, who were either looking back at him or down at the table. Angie was the only one who was looking at me.
Her face was blank, and I couldn't tell at all what she might be thinking. I didn't think that I could look her in the eye either. For the first time I was feeling like coming here was the wrong decision. I didn't want to come before, but when I decided to I knew deep down it was probably for the best. Now though...
"I wanted to put this off for a day or two and let David get a little more comfortable before telling you all, but I honestly didn't think there would ever be a good time, so I guess now is as good as any time. Is that ok David?" He asked me, I was a little surprised by that.
"Uh, yeah, I guess so." I shrugged.
"Does anyone have anything they want to say? Or any questions?" Everyone was silent. "I know that this is a lot to take in right now, and I've taken off work until you girls leave for camp, so we can try to get as situated as possible."
Tina spoke up. "We're still going to summer camp? What about David? Is he going too?"
Angie was the one to answer her. "Well sweetie, it's too late to sign him up, so he has to stay here for the summer. Besides, I think that this has already been a big enough change for him right now, I doubt that he needs any more. Is that a fair thing to say David?" She looked over to me, with a hesitant smile.
I nodded my head yes. I still didn't really know what to say, so I just stayed quiet. I glanced at Mandy who was sitting next to me. She was staring down at her lap and hadn't said a word. Beth was sitting next to her and looked like she was about to burst into tears at the slightest provocation. I started to feel guilty about what had happened earlier that day.
They were in the dark about the fact that we were related, but I wasn't. I could have told them, but I didn't. Hopefully we would get a chance to talk about this later. In my reckless hatred towards Michael, I think that I may have done some serious damage to two innocent bystanders.
"Well David," Angie said, trying to avoid the awkward elephant now sitting with us. "I can't imagine what this must be like for you, but let me be the first to say welcome to our family. I really do hope that you can in time come to think of this as your new home." She was completely sincere in her address, but I still didn't really like hearing it. Everything seemed to be getting a little too real for me.
Thankfully we all decided to go to bed, it was getting late, and I was actually starting to get tired again. I headed up to my room alone and closed the door. I didn't know what I was doing, and I was starting to realize things had gotten out of hand.
I was laying on the bed for easily a couple of hours, wondering what the hell I had gotten myself into when there was a knock on the door. I looked up to see Beth come in. She was staring at the floor and I started to feel like shit. I couldn't quite tell but I think that she had been crying.
I sat up and was looking at her in silence. I had no idea what to say.
"Did you know?" She asked me, almost whispering.
Now it was my turn to look down. "It's not that simple."
"Yes, it is. It's a simple question. Did you know?" There was a quiet fury in her voice.
"Yes. I did." I got up and walked over to her very slowly. She looked like she was ready to burst in to tears again. "Michael came to me almost a year after my mother died, and told me who he was. He never mentioned a family though. And without sounding harsh, I don't think of him as a father, and I don't really think of you as a sister. Does that make any sense?" I was now standing right next to Beth, I could smell her perfume and despite the situation I was still incredibly attracted to her.
She looked me square in the eye and set her jaw. "Would you do it again?
Now my mind was racing. My knee jerk reaction was to say 'hell fucking yes I would' and strip her down then and there, but thankfully I kept myself in check. I wanted to tell her the truth, but in all honesty I wasn't sure how she would react to that. She was willing enough when she thought I was just some guy, but now...
"Yes." Honesty won over my hesitation.
What happened next still boggles my mind. She kissed me.
I reeled my head back, expecting to get slapped, but when she pulled me into a deep passionate kiss I was stunned. After a second or two my mind shut off and my instincts kicked in. I began kissing her back, hard.
Obviously I had said the right thing, and I was giving myself a mental pat on the back for going with my gut, because this was definitely paying off. We made out for a few minutes. It was starting to get steamy when as suddenly as it started, Beth pulled back.
"Ok, that's enough for now. I needed to know if you would be honest with me, and you were. Thank you."
She turned for the door and was about to leave when I stopped her again.
"Wait, what do you mean? How do you know I was being honest?" I immediately kicked myself for asking that but it was too late. She looked back at me with a raised eyebrow.
"Do you mean you were lying just now?"
I instantly backtracked. "No! No that's not what I meant at all! I was just... I don't know, curious about how you knew that I was telling the truth."
She gave me a devilish grin that made her eyes sparkle in the night.
"I asked dad if you knew about us before you got here. He said that you didn't, but you knew that he was your father. You wanting to sleep with me again I had a hunch." She glanced down at my now throbbing cock sticking out of my boxers like a tent post. "Down boy." She said to my eager dick, and to my delighted disappointment, she twirled her head and left.
I stood there speechless. Wow, I thought to myself, there was a LOT more to Beth than I initially judged. This was going to be quite an experience.