Jay’s redhead stepsister Molly made him an offer he cannot refuse!
“Midnight, my room,” I read her message for the twelfth time now. What could my stepsister possibly want from me? Was she going to blackmail me or something, I pondered, she had me by the balls!
I was full of fear and I was yet to muster the courage to face my stepsister, and midnight was just around the corner. I sat there pondering what I could say in my defence. Nothing came to mind. Not one single argument. I was caught masturbating by my stepsister, and now I had to suffer the consequences. I’d do anything she wanted, just not to get into trouble. God, I said to myself, what would my father say if he ever found out?
The large pendulum clock was chiming in the hallway. It had struck twelve. The sound of this antique clock paralyzed me completely. I tried to move my right leg but I failed, it felt as it was glued to the floor. I took a deep breath and got to my feet shakily like an old man. It was now or never. I had to see what my stepsister had planned. The unknown was killing me.
Like a snail, I crawled towards the door. Even though the door was only a few feet away, I felt like I had walked a marathon. I got out of my room and into the corridor. Passing the large pendulum clock I got halfway to my stepsisters room. Upon, finally, arriving at her bedroom door, I stopped for a brief moment as I had to muster all the courage I had just to touch her door knob, let alone open it. I turned it and went inside.
Stepping into that room was like entering Hell itself. Only there was no Satan in there waiting for me, but my stepsister Molly. At first I couldn't make out anything in that pitch-black darkness, but steadily I recognized Molly's figure sitting on the bed. She was wearing a bathrobe, or something like that, I wasn't entirely sure. The only source of light was the faint moonlight coming from her bedroom window. She sat there, silent, and I felt that it was I who should break the ice.
“So, you wanted to see me, right?” I stood there hopelessly at her mercy, thinking about what she would say next.
“Yes,” she said.
“Well,” I replied shyly, “here I am.”
An awkward silence hung in the air. We both went completely mute. Then she finally spoke:
“I wasn't excepting this from you Jay,” she said, “I wasn't expecting this at all!”
“But---” I tried to defend myself, but to no avail.
“But nothing,” she roared, “I still don't know what to think of all this!”
“Our parents must NOT know about this,” I pleaded, “please Molly, I beg you. I'll do anything you want!”
“Hmm, anything you say,” Molly muttered, “I was hoping you'd say that. Follow me big brother.”
She got off the bed, and as she walked pass me I noticed a strange strawberry aroma that I hadn't noticed before; her perfume. She went straight for the door and into the dark corridor. I was puzzled by her request, but instinctively I went after her. Following the scent of her perfume, she led me to the guest room at the very end of the corridor. She went inside and so did I.
Two dozen candles illuminated the room. Now I could clearly see her silk bathrobe as it reflected the dim light of the candles. I shut the door behind me and just stood there, motionless.
“So, you like to watch, don't you,” said Molly before taking her silk bathrobe off, “well then, watch!”
My jaw fell as I marvelled what my younger stepsister had underneath her bathrobe. She wore her red schoolgirl skirt along with her white stockings. On top, she had her mother's olive green corset. She must've stolen it from her mother after our parents’ rough sex. This was unbelievable; I was being teased by my younger stepsister!
“Do you like it, big brother,” she said with a cute innocent voice, and I being lost for words just nodded mechanically.
“I knew you'd like it Jay,” she giggled, “that's why I tortured you the whole day, big brother, to make sure that you'd want me.”
I was still standing there like a statue, drooling all over the place. I couldn't believe my younger stepsister was such a tease. I knew something fishy was going on as soon as I saw her bouncing that round ass all day. It all made perfect sense now!
“Let's spice things up a bit,” said my stepsister, “this awkward silence is killing me!”
As soon as she finished her sentence, Molly took the remote and turned the music on, and with it myself. Billy Idol's “Flesh For Fantasy” started playing and Molly increased the volume. With the song in the background, Molly now started moving her hips to match the slow rhythm of the music. Slowly she walked towards me and grabbed me by my shirt, dragging me towards the bed. She pushed me gently, and I found myself sitting on the guest bed.
“Mm, I like this song,” said my stepsister with a giggle, “It always makes me sooo wet.” Again I nodded mechanically.
I watched as my stepsister’s hips started swaying left and right. She was dancing in that hot olive green corset, that her mother wore just a few hours ago, right in front of me. She turned around for a brief second, just enough for me to get a quick peek at that white thong underneath her red schoolgirl skirt. This, along with the tender movement of her body swaying through the air, made me rock hard. My cock was bulging in my pants and Molly noticed this straight away.
“Someone’s happy to see me,” she said as she undressed her skirt, “my ass says: hello!”
Indeed, her ass did say a heartily hello while it greedily swallowed that white lace thong with her big round butt cheeks. Molly then tenderly shook her ass a few more times before sitting on my lap. She was now pressing my hard cock with her butt cheeks as she went up and down my shaft. My cock was now buried deep between my stepsister’s ass cheeks. God, I said to myself, I’ve been fantasizing about her ass all day long, this is unreal; my stepsister’s ass feels better than I had expected!
“You’re enjoying your stepsister’s lap dance, aren’t you?” She said, “Tsk, tsk, I’ve got such a naughty stepbrother!”
I could feel a huge load building up inside my cock and If Molly hadn’t gone off my cock just now, I would’ve exploded right there. She got me so horny already; I could only guess what she had in store for me next. She stood there right in front of me looking straight into my eyes as she slowly undid her greenish corset. She set her perky tits free and I immediately made eye contact with them.
“My eyes are up here Jay!” She said with a grin.
“I know,” I replied, without breaking eye contact with her large round nipples; this made her giggle some more before she lowered herself in order to kiss and then bite my neck passionately. My nose was now slightly poking her right tit, or was it the other way round? Anyhow, I got a sudden urge to grab those hanging tits of hers and milk them. I soon got hold of them and squeezed them pretty damn hard. They were so nice and soft; I just couldn’t stop playing with them. Her tits became my new favourite toy. Meanwhile, Molly kept kissing my neck and biting me every few seconds.
“Seems somebody missed staring at my boobs,” she whispered into my ear, teasingly.
“What do you mean?”
“Who do you think put that towel at the bathroom door?” She whispered, “You were so cute when you spied on me during my shower. You made me so horny; I just couldn’t resist not touching myself.”
My cock was so hard right now that it was starting to hurt a little as my pants were squeezing my balls mercilessly. It was such a relief when Molly stood up and started to unzip my pants. She took care of my pants and immediately after that she took care of my boxers as well. My stepsister unleashed my 9 inch cock and took hold of it with her right hand.
“Mm, you’ve got a nice mushroom head big brother,” said Molly, “I really like when guys have such nice cocks.”
“It’s all yours, sis.”
Tightening her grip, Molly started stroking my cock. It felt so damn good! She was squeezing him pretty hard while she was searching for something underneath the bed. Suddenly a Nutella jar was in her hands; she opened the jar and then shoved my penis inside. Molly opened her mouth and started licking my chocolaty cock.
“Mm, I never knew your cock tasted so sweet bro.”
She continued licking around the edges of my cock until she eat all the chocolate. After that she took my monster cock inside her mouth. She swallowed him whole! I was balls deep inside my stepsister’s mouth. I watched as she was gagging on my cock and it almost made me cum inside her young mouth. My girlfriend could never deepthroat like that. Poking my stepsister’s tonsils felt so good. She took it out in order to get some air and then continued licking my glans tenderly.
Molly was such an expert. I could tell that she sucked her fair share of cocks till now. Her tender kissing and licking continued and I felt my load building up even more. I knew I couldn’t last much longer. I was going to cum inside my stepsister’s mouth very soon. She saw me shaking and knew that it was high time that cock exploded. Immediately she started deepthroating faster and faster. She looked at me with her turquoise eyes, begging for my cum. I couldn’t take this any longer; she was teasing me the whole fucking day. It was time for me to cum inside my stepsister’s mouth!
“Oh, Molly,” I sighted, “I’m going to cum.”
“Do it big brother,” she whispered, “I want to feel your warm cum sliding down my neck!”
My cock exploded, releasing wave after wave of load into my stepsister’s throat. Molly coughed a bit as she was choked by the sheer amount of my seaman; she wasn’t expecting so much so fast. However, she swallowed every last drop of it. I was still twitching when I looked into her eyes and I could tell that she wanted more.
“Oh, Molly,” I gasped, “that was the best blowjob I ever had!”
“Good, now I want something in return.”
“Name it sis, anything!”
“I want you to fuck me Jay!” Her words stung me. I wasn’t expecting this. Oral sex is one thing, but penetrating my stepsister’s 16-year-old pussy was a different story.
“Are you sure Molly?”
“Yes, I know you’re the one for me Jay. I want my stepbrother to be the first man inside my pussy.”
“Are you really okay with me popping your cherry, sis?”
“I tore my hymen due to volleyball. I just never let a guy put his penis inside of me, ever!” She said, “But now I know that you are the one. Don’t ask me why--- I just feel it. Please Jay, do this for me, big brother, please.”
Although my stepsister was blazing hot, the idea of fucking her made me feel a bit uneasy. I was hesitant at first but I guess there was no harm in doing it. Her hymen was already torn, I wouldn’t hurt her tonight as much, and God I bet her pussy was really tight. Plus I owed her for that amazing blowjob, big time.
“Alright,” I said, “get on the bed.”
She jumped onto the bed like a huntress and turned her ass towards me. She was inviting me to go doggy style on her. I took two of my fingers and I started rubbing her clit. She let out a soft moan and I increased my speed. Her pussy was already soaking wet. I shoved my two fingers deep inside her pussy. She moaned louder as I took her by surprise. Molly was right, her pussy was really tight. I could feel her muscles clutching my fingers. I fingered her pussy for a few more minutes, just in case. I took them out and saw her pussy dripping with her sweet juice.
“Just put it in already!” She roared, “Can’t you see how fucking horny I am!”
“Alright, I was just cheeking sis.”
I will never forget that moment when my cock made its first thrust into Molly’s pussy. She was so damn tight. I had to force myself inside with every thrust, even though she was soaking wet. With every thrust her moans became louder and soon they turned into yells of pleasure.
“Ohhh, myy, God! This feels soooo fucking good Jay, please don’t stop!”
I increased my speed. Her tight pussy was squeezing my hard cock. As I started ramming her pussy, I watched her big ass bounce. I was enjoying myself as much as she did. This was the best fuck I ever had. I still couldn’t believe I was balls deep in my stepsister’s pussy. Though I was gentle at first, I couldn’t keep like that for long. I started fucking her harder. She let a few more yells of approval:
“Oh, yes Jay. You’re monster cock feels so fucking good inside my pussy!”
Suddenly, she jumped off the bed and before I could ask her if something was wrong, she pushed me onto the bed and climbed me. As I sat down she swiftly took me inside of her. She started riding my cock like an animal. Her large tits were now jumping up and down in front of me and I got hold of them once again. Then she was shouting again:
“Oh, Jay I love your cock. This is so good!”
“Shh, be quiet Molly,” I whispered, “or our parents might hear us.”
“Have you seen how many bottles of wine they drank?” She said without slowing down, “They are probably dead asleep by now.”
Her continuous shouting built up my load again. I was about to cum a second time soon. She was pretty close too, I felt her pussy clenching more and more. She increased her pace and was now riding me wildly. I wanted her to cum first but I didn’t know how much more I could withstand. I felt her body beginning to tremble and she let out her final yell:
“I’M CUUUUUMING, I’M----” She shook violently and her pussy was so tight now that she was squeezing the cum out of my cock.
“OHHHH, SHIIIIT---” I couldn’t hold on any longer. I shot my first load into her pussy. I hastily tried to push her away but she impaled her razor-sharp nails into my back and attached herself to me. She was still shaking in ecstasy and didn’t want my cock out of her pussy just yet. Fuck, I said to myself as I quickly released the second and final load. I was shaking like Molly now. I never came inside a girl’s pussy before, I always pulled out. The sensation was outstanding, I just couldn’t believe it. If only a week ago somebody told me that I would fuck my stepsister I’d laugh! I never knew she was so fucking hot until today, and now there she was on top of me, her pussy filled with my offspring.
“God,” she sighed, “we have to do that again sometime.”
“Molly, I have to tell you something.”
“What is it big brother?”
“I think I came inside your pussy.” I said shyly.
“Good.” She smiled.
“Wait... What?” I jumped off the bed, “how can that be good?”
“Relax Jay. I’m on the pill. I should’ve told you. Sorry.” She made a cute puppy face and I just couldn’t be mad at her. Anyhow, this was great news. I just loved how I came deep inside her pussy, I wanted more.
Exhausted, we kissed each other for the first time. It was the most passionate kiss I ever had, yet so tender and innocent. Molly was such a cute girl but feisty at the same time. I watched her short ginger hair as we lay down onto the bed and gradually both fell asleep.
I woke up early next morning to find myself alone in the guest bed. I was hoping Molly would still be there when I woke up, just like it happened in my dream last night. However, I just remembered that our parents might still be at home. Molly was probably just playing safe. I started and dressed myself before I left the guest room.
Upon arriving to my room I heard my phone ringing. It was a message. When I picked it up, I noticed I had 4 missed calls and a message; all from my dear girlfriend. Gosh, I thought, I totally forgot about my girlfriend, she must be really angry. I opened my inbox and read the message: “Hey sweetie, how are ya? What you wanna do tonight? Love, Katie <3”
To be honest, I wasn’t really in the mood for her today after all those intense moments with Molly. I couldn’t stop thinking about my stepsister. That’s why I lied to my girlfriend in my reply: “Hey honey, I can’t go out tonight. I’ve got a stomach-ache, sorry! Love you, Jay.”
As soon as I sent her the message my stomach started growling. Speaking of a stomach-ache, I said to myself, I’ll sure as Hell get one if I don’t eat something soon! I dashed for the kitchen and opened the fridge. I made myself a nice chicken sandwich and I ate it like a savage in three hungry bites. Upon finishing my breakfast, I heard a noise coming from the living room. Someone’s coming, I thought.
Indeed, someone was coming, my stepsister Molly. She was wearing her silk bathrobe again. My heart stopped as I watched her walk slowly towards me, with her short red hair and round turquoise eyes. She grew hotter each time I saw her. I still can’t believe I fucked her last night. It all felt so unreal, like a dream. She threw her arms around me and squeezed me passionately.
“Good morning, big brother,” she kissed my cheek, “did you sleep well?”
“Like a lamb,” I answered.
“Good,” she said, “I felt really bad for not telling you I was on the pill last night. So I thought I might make it up to you.”
“Oh, what did you have in mind?” I inquired, upon which she knelt in front of me.
She took her bathrobe off and I could see her perky tits once more. Immediately she unzipped my pants and went for my cock. My sis is such a nymph, I thought to myself, I’m such a lucky guy. I was already rock hard the moment she entered the kitchen. She took a firm grip of my cock and started stroking it. After that she slowly licked around the edges of my cock, like she did last night. I let out a soft moan and then she went for my balls. She took my left ball into her mouth and started sucking on it. I felt the sweet warmth of her mouth as her tongue kept licking my ball. Molly knew the definition of a good blowjob. My right ball soon followed as she continued stroking my cock. I felt my load filling up already, but I didn’t want to cum just yet.
Molly finally took my cock deep inside her mouth. It was time for some deepthroating again. As she increased her pace I watched as her perky tits went bouncing up and down; her nipples staring directly at me. She had such a hot little body. I can’t believe I was so blind for all these years. Was I gay?
My thoughts were interrupted by the phone ringing on the kitchen counter. I managed to reach it with my right arm and answered. It was my stepmom.
“Hey there sweetie, is everything alright?”
“Hey mom, everything is fine, don’t worry.”
“How’s Molly doing?” After hearing her question I looked down and saw my stepsister still sucking my monster cock.
“Oh, Molly’s doing just fine.” Upon hearing this, Molly increased her speed. She wanted me to cum into her mouth so bad. She was enjoying this awkward situation. I felt my load building up, but I tried my best to fight it.
“Great to see you two getting along so well,” said my stepmother, “you take good care of your little sister. Your dad and I won’t be home till dinner, something came up at the office.”
“Okay mom,” I replied, trying not to pant as Molly went full swing. It was only a matter of seconds before I filled her mouth again.
“That’s all sweetie,” said my stepmom, “see ya tonight--”
“Bye!” I didn’t let her finish the sentence and hung up. I swiftly took my cock out of Molly’s mouth and started cumming all over her pretty face.
“OHHHHH, SHHIII---” I exploded, my cum falling on her short red hair, then her nose and both her eyes. She didn’t close them in time and I unleashed my load in both of them. Molly’s face was completely covered with my children. I never came this much before. It felt so good. I was so damn proud when I looked at the mess I had made. Her face was dripping with my cum and her boobs were now slowly getting covered with my spunk as well.
I gave Molly a napkin and she, unfortunately, wiped her pretty face. I was still in ecstasy after that amazing blowjob that only my stepsister could give me. We were both enjoying the silence before Molly finally asked me:
“Well, what did my mother want?”
“Hmm, seems we got the rest of the day all to ourselves, sis!”