My daughter was playing Truth or Dare with her girlfriends on her birthday, and they asked me to join.
I turned off the tv, stretching and rolling my neck as I stood, smiling at the squealing, happy ruckus coming from downstairs. It seemed like only yesterday that Hailey had been bouncing on my knee, giggling happily in her little pink footie pyjamas. And now here she was, on the cusp of adulthood, celebrating her birthday with her friends.
I walked down the stairs, knocking on the wall to announce my presence. “Safe for me to come down?” I called, and was greeted by a loud burst of laughter.
“Hey Dad. What's up?” Hailey turned to ask, all five of them smiling brightly (and maybe just a touch guiltily?) as they looked up at me from their spots on the couches and chairs they'd pulled into a loose circle in the middle of the room. They were all so adorable... and very, very sexy, in their cute pastel tank tops, and tiny little booty-shorts. I kept my gaze rigidly fixed to my daughter's eyes, hoping like hell that none of them had any idea what their nubile teenage bodies were doing to me.
“Nothing sweetie, I'm just about to turn in for the night. Wanted to check if you girls needed anything before I did.”
“Nope, all good!” she smiled. “Night!”
“Unless you want to come join the game with us, that is!” Erica, the leader and undisputed troublemaker-in-chief of their little tribe, chimed in, causing renewed squeals and giggles all around.
“Truth or dare,” Hailey admitted, rolling her eyes.
“Ah...” I smirked. “Probably not a good idea, then.”
“Come on, Mr. H! You can play! It'll be fun!” That was Andi this time, her pale cheeks blushing brilliantly. That was redheads for you... and to think, I'd always had her pegged as the good-girl of the group! But... that wasn't really fair, I knew. She was still a good girl—they all were! Testing an occasional limit was perfectly natural at their age. I was just having trouble reconciling my memories of the sweet, innocent little girls they had once been, with the beautiful, confident, sexy young women they had become!
There was much shrieking, pushing, and laughing after Andi's invitation. I honestly couldn't make out half of what they were saying to each other, they were squealing so much. But to my shock, it seemed a consensus was forming. Tall, gazelle-like brunette Erica didn't surprise me; that girl had never met a boundary she wouldn't push! And of course that meant that tiny little blonde Vicki was automatically on board as well; she actually had a surprisingly good head on her shoulders, if you could ever get her alone for a minute, but she'd been following Erica like a puppy ever since the five of them had started kindergarten together. Andi was the surprise; busty, skinny, deceptively innocent-looking Andi, shocking me with the way she was suddenly fluttering her big green eyes at me, trying to flirt. Even shy, nerdy little Lin seemed to agree.
“It's your call, sweetheart,” I told Hailey.
“I think you'd better stay,” she giggled. “I might have a rebellion on my hands, if I tried sending you away now!” The others all laughed, and Hailey moved aside on her section of couch, patting the spot next to her. I leaned down and kissed her in her hair first, inhaling the fresh, floral scent of her beautiful chestnut waves, then sat.
“So, the rules we're using are pretty simple,” Hailey explained for me. “We take turns around the circle. When it's your turn, you spin the bottle, and whoever it points to is the one who chooses your truth or dare for you, whichever one you pick. If you chicken out, you have to take a shot.”
“And take off a piece of clothing, too!” Erica chimed in, to a roar of protest from the others. “What? Why not? We didn't have any guys playing, before, so there wasn't any point! Now that we do, it should be take a drink and lose a piece of clothing! Who agrees? And socks don't count, by the way!”
There was some good-natured grumbling about it, but predictably they all came around, letting Erica have her way as always.
“It's your turn next,” Hailey smiled at me, patting me on my knee.
“Of course it is,” I rolled my eyes, but I'd been expecting that.
“And here! You should take a shot, too, to catch up with the rest of us,” Erica continued. I sighed, but I'd more or less been expecting that, too. I picked up the shot she'd poured for me, toasted them in the air, and downed it in one go.
“Gah!” I grimaced at the taste, rolling my tongue around in my mouth. “What the hell is that stuff?”
“Umm... strawberry vodka?” Erica said, looking uncertainly at the label. “It's not that bad, is it? I got the one in the prettiest bottle, I thought it would be good.”
“More like strawberry-flavoured paint-thinner!” I shuddered, turning to Hailey. “Run up to my office, will you, sweetie? Bring back my scotch, from the cabinet in the corner.”
“'Kay,” she giggled, bouncing up and running to do as I'd asked. I decided not to wait, giving the bottle a spin and landing on Lin. I looked her in the eyes, trying to decide. “Truth,” I said.
“Hmm...” she said, chewing her lip as she stared across the circle at me. “Okay, I know! What's the kinkiest thing you've ever done in bed?”
Ooohs and aaahs erupted around the circle.
“Lin! I'm surprised... and a little impressed!” I laughed, enjoying the way it made her blush. Not as much as Andi did, that's true... but Lin's skin was on the lighter side of the Korean spectrum, and really quite fetching with the pink rising in her cheeks.
“Okay, I'm back, what did I miss?” Hailey announced, a little out of breath as she jumped the last few stairs, hurrying back around to her place.
“Nothing yet,” I told her. “I was just about to ask Lin to clarify; do you want to know the kinkiest thing I've done specifically in bed, like you asked? Or the kinkiest thing I've done overall, in a bed or out?”
“Oh! Uhh...” she said, her eyes going wide, her blush rising even more. “Kinkiest overall, please!”
“You sure about this, sweetie?” I turned to Hailey. “Last chance to decide this was a bad idea, before you start learning things about me you can't un-hear.”
“Umm...” she chewed her lip. “No, I think I'm okay... you can go ahead.”
“Okay... but don't say I didn't warn you!” I shrugged, taking a deep breath and turning back to face Lin. “Back when I was in college, maybe... two and a half months after I started dating Hailey's mom, Jeannie, she came to me with a request. Her younger sister was really, super nervous about losing her virginity, not wanting to do it with some random asshole who only wanted another notch on his belt. So... she asked me if I'd take care of it for her, instead.”
“Auntie Sarah?” Hailey gasped, her eyes going wide.
“'Fraid so,” I grinned at her. “Told you you might learn things you didn't want to know. We had a threesome together... though of course the two of them didn't actually do anything to each other, being sisters and all. At least, nothing other than a little accidental kissing, when they were sharing giving me a blowjob. We made an entire weekend out of it, sleeping in the same bed, with me taking turns going back and forth between them as often as I could get it up. So... we're going clockwise, right? So it's Erica's turn next?”
It took a moment for them all to shake their brains back into gear, after the revelation I'd just dropped. But Erica spun, the bottle landing on Hailey this time, and she decided on truth as well.
“Hmm...” Hailey hummed, tapping a finger on her chin as she stared into Erica's eyes. “Oh, I know! Before you started dating Ryan, who did you always tell me you fantasized about having take your virginity?”
“No!” Erica gasped. “You promised you wouldn't tell!”
“I'm not telling!” Hailey laughed, shaking her head. “You're telling! Either that, or your taking a shot and losing a piece of clothing!”
“Oh, God...” Erica moaned, closing her eyes. “I... I always dreamed it would be you, Mr. H.. I always wanted you to be my first.”
“Wow... Erica...” I wasn't sure what to say. “I'm flattered.”
“It, uhh...” she gulped. “It's too late now. Ryan... oh, hell! Just spin the damn bottle already, will you Vic?”
Vicki giggled, and did as she'd been told. Her first spin landed right back on herself, and the second landed on Andi. “Dare,” Vicki declared, with more confidence than I would have had, with the way this game was already going.
“Don't worry, I'll give you an easy one...” Andi smiled, a wicked gleam in her eye. “All you have to do... is give Mr. H. a kiss on the lips!”
“No fair!” Vicki objected, glancing nervously over at me. “Dares aren't allowed to involve anyone else! Only the person whose turn it is, and whoever the bottle points to! That's the rule!”
“That's okay... I don't mind,” I offered with a shrug.
“You... you don't?” she gasped.
“Umm...” Hailey piped in. “You should probably know... you'd be Vicki's first kiss with a boy. That's why it looks like her head is about to explode right now.”
“Oh, God...” Vicki moaned, hiding her eyes behind her hands.
“Oh! Umm...” I said, my mind whirring. “You don't have to, Vicki... if that's the rule, then that's the rule. You can demand that Andi picks a different dare, if you like. That's only fair.”
“Are... are you sure you wouldn't mind, if I did?” she eventually asked, nervously peeking out from between her fingers.
“Not at all,” I smiled as warmly as I could, and she slowly peeled herself out of her seat. I stood as well, meeting her in the middle of the circle, softly brushing a strand of long blonde hair away from her face. I leaned down, slowly, staring into her eyes until the moment they closed, and met her lips with mine. She was nervous, timid... but I pressed, warm and soft, taking her hip in one hand, my other moving up to the back of her head, cradling her there. She moaned, trembling against me, and I held her, not pushing, not using any tongue, just kissing her soft and slow, until she finally, slowly pulled away, her eyes still closed, an enormous, happy smile on her lips.
She giggled nervously, scurrying back to her seat to much hooting and hollering from the others, as I regained my seat as well.
Lin spun next, the bottle landing on Andi again. Unwilling to risk a dare, after what she'd seen her make Vicki do, she picked truth.
“Okay then...” Andi grinned. “How many times per day do you masturbate?”
“Ugh!” Lin rolled her eyes, all the others bursting into laughter. Apparently this was not the first time someone had asked that question, and they already knew the answer. “One, as soon as my alarm wakes me up in the morning.” Lin held a hand up in front of her, raising a finger to keep count. “Two, when I'm in the shower getting ready for school. Three, four, and five, as soon as I get home from school, to make up for not being able to while I was there.” Her second hand came up as well. “Six, just before my Mom and Dad get home, and I have to go help get supper ready. Seven, right after supper. Eight and nine, sometimes ten, right before bed, to tire myself out enough that I can actually fall asleep.”
“Wow, I...” I shook my head, hardly able to believe it. Shy, nerdy little Lin? “I'm impressed! Doesn't it... I mean, doesn't it ever get sore?”
“You have no idea!” she sighed, shaking her head. “But I'd rather be sore, than go without cumming!”
“Well... I suppose I can't fault you there,” I chuckled. Ten times a day... I'd always had a more than healthy sex drive, but even when I'd been the girls' age, ten would have been pushing it! Although... maybe on that one weekend with Jeannie and Sarah, come to think of it. We'd had better things on our minds than trying to keep count, at the time... but it may well have been somewhere in that neighbourhood, looking back.
“My turn!” Andi announced next, leaning down and spinning. And was it just me, or was she arching her back specifically to give me a view down her cleavage as she did it? The bottle made barely one full rotation before coming to rest pointed directly at me, the girls all groaning.
“Suck it!” she laughed. “The rules say at least one full rotation, and that was one full rotation! A little bit more, even!” She stared me straight in my eyes, licking her lips. “Dare!”
“Dare, is it?” I grinned back at her, considering my options. Part of me wanted to pick something silly and goofy, just to embarrass her. But staring into those beautiful green eyes of hers... Who was I kidding? Of course I wasn't going to do that.
“Okay then... twenty bra-less jumping jacks, right here, facing me!” I grinned, pointing at the ground directly in front of my feet.
“Gladly!” she grinned back, hopping up and stepping over. She stared straight into my eyes—and quickly stripped off her top!
“Oh!” I gasped, my eyes going wide as she reached behind herself, unclasping her bra as well. “I said braless, not topless! I thought you'd just take it off from underneath!”
“Then you should have been more specific, if that was what you wanted!” she giggled. “You didn't say I couldn't take off my top, too, so this is what you get!”
She started to jump, and oh my God... her tits were incredible! Even better than I'd imagined! Twenty arrived far too soon, and she quickly slipped back into her top, not bothering with the bra, her thick, suckable nipples still proudly displayed through the thin cotton as she regained her seat.
Hailey was up next, picking dare when the bottle pointed to Vicki.
“Okay, let me think...” Vicki giggled. “You... oh, I know! You have to go to your room, get your biggest toy, and put it inside you! And you have to keep it in there, until someone else dares you to take it out!”
“No way!” Hailey gasped in shock. “You can't be serious... My dad is here!”
“So?” Vicki giggled. “At least I'm not making you put it in where he can watch you doing it! But if you've got such a problem with it, then take off your top and take a drink!”
“You suck...” Hailey grumbled. “I am so getting you back for this!” But she stood and clomped up the stairs to uproarious laughter, which only increased as she came mincing carefully back down a few minutes later, having swapped her shorts for a pair of sweatpants.
“You have to prove you did it!” Erica demanded, to instant agreement from everyone else. Hailey sighed, closing her eyes... and pulled her sweats down, revealing the characteristic outline of a pair of rubber testicles just barely hidden under her thin little cotton panties. She yanked her sweats back up again after less than a second, but there was no doubting what she'd done—and no way in hell I was ever going to forget the sight! I helped her ease herself gently back down to the couch beside me, wincing all the way, then reached for the bottle again.
“Wait...” Erica interrupted. “Before you spin... what do you say, every time we go all the way around the circle, we all take a shot and take off one piece of clothing. Just to make it more interesting?”
There were nervous glances all around, but eventually everyone agreed. They only had the one shot glass, so we had to take turns; seeing the looks on their faces as they got their first tastes of decent scotch was worth the price of admission, right there! Andi already had her bra off, so that was the piece she picked. Vicki did the same, reaching in underneath the way I'd expected Andi to do earlier. Erica, Lin, and Hailey all took off their tops, revealing three shockingly tiny, lacy little bras, as I took off my shirt as well. And... was that a pair of barbell nipple piercings I could see, poking out against the thin fabric of Erica's bra? When the hell had she gotten those? I forced my eyes back down to the bottle and gave it a spin, landing on Hailey this time.
“Truth,” I said again, figuring that was safest. She may have been my daughter... but I wasn't taking chances.
“Umm...” she said, blushing cutely. “Okay... what's your favourite position, for having sex?”
“Hmm...” I said, thinking. I was surprised that she wanted to know that about me, but compared to some of the other things she could have asked, I knew I was getting off easy. “I guess it depends... I like pretty much everything, really. The only thing I don't like, is when we screw up our positioning, and the girl ends up catching one of my balls between her ass and my thigh! But overall... I think it's probably a tie between cowgirl, and doggy. Ideally, the girl starts off riding me for a while, letting me play with her tits, until she's cum a few times already, and her legs start giving out. Then we switch to doggy, and I do her hard and fast to finish myself off. But then... I also really like shower-sex, too, and neither of those work in the shower. There, I like pushing her up against the wall, her tits sliding up and down against the tile as I do her from behind. So... some combination of those three, I guess, probably counts as my favourite.”
Erica spun next, landing on Lin, and picked dare this time.
“Easy choice,” she giggled. “Put on some music on your phone, and give Mr. H. a lap dance!”
“Umm... okay,” Erica blushed. “You, uhh... you don't mind, do you?” she asked me.
“Not at all,” I smiled. “As a matter of fact, I'm looking forward to it!”
She giggled, smiling shyly but happily as she grabbed her phone and quickly pulled up a song. The speakers weren't the greatest, making the base sound tinny and weak, but the music was the last thing I cared about. Erica moved into place in front of me, biting her lip and swaying her hips, seductively messing her long brunette hair. She moved closer, putting her foot up on the couch next to my hip, rolling her hips, slowly fucking her pussy at my face in time with the music, her tiny little shorts exposing a long length of toned, skinny thigh.
She dropped, suddenly, straight into my lap, timing it perfectly with the song; I was starting to strongly suspect this wasn't the first time she'd done something like this! She grabbed my hands, placing them on her hips as she started grinding herself into my lap, leaning in against my ear.
“I can feel your cock, Mr. H.,” she whispered, quiet enough I knew only I would hear, running her hands up and down my naked chest as she continued to gyrate in my lap. “It feels really, really big... it's making my pussy so wet! Do you want to feel my pussy? Do you want to fuck me, Mr. H.? I'll let you, if you want to. I'll wait until everyone else is asleep, and I'll sneak up to you room, and I'll let you do anything you want! I'll... I'll even let you put it in my asshole, Mr. H.! I've never done that before, but I'll let you do it, if you want! You can take my anal cherry... or anything else you want! All you have to do is say yes!”
She lifted her left leg, high and straight, showing off her phenomenal flexibility, passing it in front of my face as she twisted around to face away from me, before shifting back into the center of my lap again. She grabbed my hands from her hips, dragging them up to her tits! I'm not sure who gasped louder, her or me, as I reflexively squeezed them through her tiny, lacy little bra! They were amazing! Small, yes, but perfectly suited to her tall, slender body, her erect, barbell-pierced nipples poking firmly into my palms.
I gruffly cleared my throat, struggling to get control of my voice, before whispering back into her ear. “That is a terrible idea, sweetie!” That was the best I could manage. I didn't tell her 'yes', like every cell of my body was screaming at me to do... but I couldn't make myself tell her 'no'.
The song eventually came to an end, and Erica retreated back to her chair. I was seriously struggling now, my cock feeling like it was about to stage a mutiny against my stupid, stubborn brain, and tear its way out of my pants on its own! I wasn't the only one who had been so affected by Erica's performance; I could barely even see the colour in the girls' eyes now, they were all so widely dilated with arousal. There couldn't have been a dry set of panties in the bunch! Hailey, especially, was now rocking herself in her seat beside me, slowly grinding herself on the toy Vicki had made her shove up inside!
“My turn!” Vicki breathed, nearly panting with desire as she hurried to spin, her cute, tiny nipples standing out like glass cutters through her thin little top. It stopped on Hailey this time, and with Vicki's eyes flashing wide in fear she instantly chose truth. I didn't blame her! Having that toy inside her had to be a constant reminder of my daughter's desire for revenge.
“Hmph...” Hailey grumped. Oh, yeah; she was still ticked. But then she grinned. “Oh, I know! Whose pussies do you like eating most, ranked from best to worst, and why?”
Vicki's eyes shot to mine, but only for a moment before she averted her gaze, covering her eyes behind her hands again as her cheeks burst into an enormous pink blush. “Oh, God...” she started to tremble. “Yours... yours is best. It's... it's sweeter than anybody else's, it doesn't taste as strong. And you always make tons of cream when you cum, it... it makes me feel proud, like I know I've done a good job! Then... Erica's. I love the way her piercing feels when I play with it with my tongue! Then Andi... I like it, a lot, it just can't quite compete with the other two! And then Lin. Sorry... I really like your pussy... but it's your pubes! They tickle my nose, and always make me feel like I need to sneeze!”
“Sorry,” Lin murmured, self-consciously wrapping her arms around her waist, staring down at the floor. “I want to shave... but my mom doesn't understand! You guys know how traditional she is... she thinks shaving down there is only for whores! She'd kill me, if I did it and she ever found out!”
“We know,” Vicki said, moving from her seat to give Lin a comforting hug. “We still like it! Really!”
“You do? You promise you aren't just saying that?” Forceful exclamations of agreement came from all around, and it was all I could do not to visibly react. All five of them? I'd wondered, on occasion, if there might not be some occasional experimenting going on. But this sounded like significantly more than that!
“Love you guys!” Lin finally said, smiling happily as she wiped away a last, stray tear, then reaching for the bottle. She gave it a solid spin, and if came to rest pointing squarely at me. Lin bit her lip, staring into my eyes, and eventually decided on truth.
“Okay...” I said, thinking back to what she'd asked me. “I'll return your own question... but I'm going to change it a little bit. Instead of telling us the kinkiest thing you've ever done... tell us your biggest, kinkiest fantasy that you've never done!”
“Oooh! Good question!” Andi praised. “You found something I actually don't know the answer to already! Anybody?” The girls were all shaking their heads, smiling excitedly. A rare occurrence then, finding something they didn't already know about each other.
“I, uhh...” Lin began, nervously biting her lip, a blush already rising in her cheeks, staring down at her hands as she wrung them in her lap. “I... I guess, what I really want most is, uh... oh, God. I...” She winced her eyes closed, gathering her courage. “I... I really want to be raped!”
“Raped?” I gasped in surprise, as did the others.
She nodded, her eyes still tightly closed. “I... I want to be tied up, or held down. I... I want him to force himself on me. I want him to be rough! I want him to hurt me, inside! And... and no matter how much I fight, or scream, or cry, or beg, I... I don't want him to stop, no matter what! Not until he cums in me! I want him to use me! I... I want to be nothing but a cunt for him! Something for him to use... any time, anywhere, and any way that he likes!”
“Wow, that...” Hailey gulped beside me. “That is so fucking hot!”
“Really?” Lin gasped, her head snapping up, tears of worry and shame now clearly visible on her cheeks. “You don't... you don't think I'm a freak? You don't think I'm disgusting, for wanting this?”
“Of course not!” Hailey exclaimed, vigorously shaking her head. “How could you ever think that? I... I don't know if I could ever actually go through with it, myself... But it would be so fucking hot, watching it happening to you!”
“Totally!” “Fuck, yes!” “God, I would kill to see that!” The sentiment was universal, and I was keeping my lips firmly sealed. This was a moment for the girls, not me. Especially not since I had absolutely no interest whatsoever in watching Lin being raped...
I wanted to be the one doing it to her myself!
Once they'd gotten Lin sufficiently reassured, it was Andi's turn again. And again she tried her trick with the bottle—but she undershot it this time, landing on Hailey, instead. But she still picked dare. Did Andi have a secret she didn't want me to hear? I was starting to wonder.
“Okay, Andi...” Hailey grinned. “I dare you... to sit in my dad's lap, and let him play with your tits however he likes until its your next turn to spin!”
Andi's eyes flashed wide, and she squealed in surprise and joy, popping out of her seat and rushing over to our couch. “You are the bestest!” She bent down to Hailey first, kissing her forcefully on the lips, before plopping herself down in my lap, wriggling happily as she rubbed herself on my cock. I chuckled into the side of her neck, giving her a soft kiss just behind her ear... then reached up under her top. She shuddered adorably, her eyes fluttering closed. And Oh! My! God! I'd thought I'd been getting a treat watching her doing jumping jacks, but this! They were so firm, and heavy, and hot in my hands! And the tighter I squeezed, the more she seemed to like it!
The other girls seemed nearly as mesmerized as I was, but eventually Hailey broke herself out of her stupor enough to spin again, landing in Andi's empty spot.
“Truth,” Andi mouthed at her silently, and Hailey raised an eyebrow in question. Sitting right next to each other, now that Andi was in my lap, there was no way any of the others could hear. “Truth. Trust me.”
“Okay... I pick truth,” Hailey said.
“Where is your favourite place to masturbate?” Andi asked, not missing a beat, and Hailey's eyes went wide.
“Umm...” she twisted in her seat to look straight into my eyes, swallowing nervously. “I... my favourite place to masturbate is... is in your bed! Right when I get home from school, before you get home from work. I... I love the way it smells like you! It always makes me cum so, so much harder than doing it anywhere else!”
“Wow, baby, I...” I smiled. “Thank you. That may be the sweetest thing anyone has ever said to me.”
“You... you aren't mad?” she timidly asked. “That I've been sneaking in there without your permission? And doing... that?”
“Why would I be mad?” I grinned, leaning over to lovingly kiss her cheek, and taking the opportunity to softly whisper into her ear. “My only regret is that you've never invited me to watch!”
Her eyes flashed wide as I leaned back into my spot, her blush rivalling even Andi's, she was turning so pink!
“Okay, that's the end of round two... everybody lose a piece of clothing, and get ready to drink!” Erica declared.
Andi reluctantly pushed herself out of my lap, bending over at her waist as she reached back to her hips, giggling wickedly as she slowly, teasingly slid her booty shorts down her thighs before letting them drop. She was wearing the tiniest little white thong, the perfect, smooth globes of her tiny, round little ass out on irresistible display—I squeezed, she moaned, shimmying herself in my hands. Then she stood, biting her lip and glancing meaningfully down. 'Daddy's Girl', her panties read, in cutsie, curvy pink ***********, right in front of my face.
“Is that so?” I grinned, standing as I let my hand reach out. She gasped as I squeezed, then threw herself at my chest as I started to rub, grabbing the back of my head with both hands, pulling me down for a frenetic, passionate kiss!
“Do the honours?” I moaned into her lips, and she broke our kiss with the most adorable look of confusion on her face, I just had to laugh. “My pants, I mean. I need to lose a piece of clothing, still.
“Oh!” she giggled. “Don't mind if I do!” She returned to our kiss, fumbling blindly at my belt. And with other things, as well, at which she seemed to have considerably more skill! But she eventually got my pants undone, letting them fall to my ankles, and I stepped out of them and kicked them aside, taking a look around. Bottoms were now universally a thing of the past; I was being treated to the sight of five tiny, adorable little sets of panties, Andi and Vicki the only two still wearing their tank tops, the other three in bras.
“I'll take that!” Andi announced, accepting the first shot of whiskey Erica poured. “Actually... You know what? Here, hold this a sec!” I accepted it as she'd asked, quirking my brow. She just grinned, and quickly doffed her shirt again before taking back the glass, carefully placing it between her tits and crossing her arms across her chest, squeezing them together and holding it in place. “Okay, now you can drink!” she announced, giving me a saucy, seductive wink.
I laughed, and eagerly bent to my appointed task—no hands, of course! Not unless you counted caressing her sexy, skinny little waist. I honestly had no idea how she could be that skinny, and still have tits that big! But frankly, I couldn't have cared less—I was just enjoying the hell out of the fact that she did! I took the rim of the glass between my teeth, and tossed back my shot, letting the familiar burn course down my throat before dropping the glass into my hand. I hadn't done titty-shots since college! Speaking of which...
“Fill me up again, would you, sweetie?” I asked Erica, holding out the glass. Andi smiled, offering me her cleavage again... but I had something a little bit different in mind.
I dropped to my knees, wrapping one arm around her lower back for stability... and took her thick, hard nipple fully into my mouth! She gasped, her beautiful green eyes flashing wide in shock, then fluttering closed in pleasure as I began to suck. I gave her a few moments to enjoy it... Okay, who am I kidding? I gave us both a few moments to enjoy it! Then I opened my mouth, positioned the shot glass just under her collar bone, and slowly began to pour, allowing a thin trickle of fluid to course down her breast, off her nipple, and directly into my waiting mouth!
I swallowed my shot, finishing with another slow, deep suck, and a long lick up the slope of her breast to clean her off, before I stood.
“So... who's next?”
There was no shortage of squealing and pushing, as I'd known there would be. Hailey was the only one holding back, still struggling with the effects of having that toy up her pussy. One by one the girls stepped up, taking their turns at the Fountain of Andi. Thankfully, Andi didn't try to suggest taking her own shot off the end of my cock; alcohol and urethras do not mix, as I could personally attest! She did ask for me to be the one to feed it to her, which I was happy to do, having her tilt her head back and slowly dribbling it into her mouth. Then it was back to our prior positions, except now with only the thin fabric of my boxers and a tiny little strip of thong separating my cock from Andi's extremely hot, wet, and eager little teenaged cunt!
My turn next, but with my hands full of Andi's tits, I asked Hailey to make my spin. It stopped in almost the exact same spot her last one had, on Andi's empty chair.
“Truth,” I said again. Fantasizing about it was one thing... but I was not about to give her a chance to dare me to fuck her, which I was quite sure was exactly what she had in mind at the moment!
“Hmph!” she grumped, confirming my suspicions. But I took her cute little earlobe between my lips, making her giggle and instantly improving her mood. “Okay... have you ever masturbated while thinking about any of your daughter's friends?” she grinned. “And if so, who?”
“Yes,” I answered, giving her a teasing little nibble to make her squeak. “But that's two questions, not one, so I'm not answering the second one.”
“No fair!” she tried to object, but she was overruled this time; that had been two questions, clear as could be. Besides which, the others were all obviously feeling jealous over Andi's position in my lap and the attention I was paying to her tits, so none of them were inclined to do her any favours at the moment.
Then it was Erica's turn again, picking dare when the bottle landed on Lin.
“Okay... I dare you to masturbate until you cum, or until someone dares you to stop!”
Erica's eyes went wide, swallowing nervously as she looked over at me, but she didn't object, obediently slipping her hand in under her panties and beginning to play as I watched.
Vicki's turn next, and the bottle landed on Erica. She was licking her lips, staring back and forth between her and Andi, and picked dare.
“I dare you... unnnhh,” Erica moaned, beginning to pick up pace between her thighs. “I dare you... to do whatever dare Hailey picks for you to do!”
“What? No! No fair!” she gasped, as the others all just laughed. That was a perfectly legitimate dare, they all agreed.
“Hmm... let's see...” Hailey grinned, clearly loving the look of dread on Vicki's face as she made her wait. Was she going to use this opportunity to finally get the toy out of her pussy? I wasn't so certain. Earlier in the game, sure, that was definitely what she would have done... but whether the others had noticed it yet or not, I'd been paying closer attention; I'd seen the way she'd been rocking herself on it, more and more vigorously the longer the game went on. “I dare you... to spin the bottle again, and give oral sex to whoever it lands on! Until you make them cum, or someone dares you to stop!”
“Seriously?” she gasped, looking over at me, blushing brightly and staring down at the ground, unable to meet my eyes. “But... what if it lands on your dad? You know I've never done that before!”
“So?” Hailey laughed. “You made me have a toy inside me, in front of my own dad! At least whatever you do, your parents will never know about it! If you don't want to risk it, then take a drink and lose another piece of clothing! Your choice!”
“Oh, God...” Vicki moaned, chewing her lip. But she eventually leaned down, and gave the bottle the hardest spin she could. It spun, and spun... and finally came to rest, pointing almost exactly half-way between Erica and me.
The debate raged, but only the three not directly involved, Lin, Andi, and Hailey, got a vote, and they decided the bottle pointed just slightly more towards me. I'm not sure how fair that decision really was, and how much they all just wanted to watch cute little Vicki's first time sucking a cock! The fact that Erica was already masturbating for her own dare may also have played a part. Whatever the truth, Vicki was a good sport about it once the decision was made. Nervous, certainly, there was no denying that! But she slipped out of her chair, submissively crawling over to me. Andi spread her thighs further apart, and I lifted us both, letting Vicki get in there to pull down my boxers. And when I finally sprang free, the gasp of surprise and awe from five lovely teenage throats was music to my ears! Unsurprisingly, I was hard as a fucking rock after everything that had already taken place!
“Oh, wow, Mr. H...” Vicki purred, staring and licking her lips, taking it into her hands and gently starting to stroke. She leaned in, softly kissing my crown, and slowly, timidly took me into her mouth, her beautiful blue eyes going cutely cross-eyed as she began to suck.
“Your turn now, I think Lin,” I reminded her.
“Oh! Uh... yeah, right.” She said, regretfully tearing her eyes away, giving the bottle a spin, landing on Vicki's empty spot. But there wasn't even a conversation on the subject, nobody wanted to distract her; we all just agreed it was close enough to pointing at Erica, so we let her take the turn instead. After all that time she'd still only had one turn to pick, after all, and she'd given that turn to Hailey. So it only seemed fair, and Lin picked dare.
“I dare you... ungh... to get... the rest of the way naked, put clothes pins on ungh... on your nipples, and ungh... leave them there until someone else takes them off!” Erica was really going at herself hard now, and was having a hell of a time trying to speak clearly.
“Oh! Uhh...” Lin blushed. “Okay, I guess... but... do you guys even have clothes pins?”
“I don't think so, actually. Hailey?” She shook her head. Which relieved me quite a bit, knowing that there was only one use to which she could have been putting them, if she had. “I have some binder clips upstairs in my office, if those will work?”
“Uhhh... okay.” Lin stood, and nervously began to strip. She was such a little cutie, with high, firm round breasts, quite a bit larger than I would have guessed. Such a shame that she kept herself hidden under those baggy t-shirts and hoodies she was always wearing! The panties came down, revealing the promised bush, with just the tiniest hint of bright pink lips hidden beneath, and she disappeared up the stairs.
“Andi? Your turn! You have to get out of his lap now and spin!” Erica reminded her between gasps.
“Do I have to?” she whined. “Can't I just skip my turn, and stay here instead?”
Everyone laughed, but there was no way they were going to let that happen. Probably hoping to clear the path for their own turns in my lap, I thought. If not something even worse!
Andi pouted, but obediently returned to her spot. And surprise, surprise, she made it land on me again.
“Dare,” she said, hopefully biting her lip as she stared into my eyes, clearly wishing for a return to my lap. I was tempted, I really, really was... but there was something I wanted to watch her do even more.
“Get naked. Take that toy out of my daughter's pussy, and lick it clean. Then put it in the middle of the floor, and bounce on it until you make yourself cum for me!”
Her stunning green eyes swelled nearly to the size of saucers. “Yes, Daddy!” she moaned, trembling with need. She stood and stripped as fast as she could, never taking her eyes from mine, her amazing, shaved little lips flushed an even more astonishing pink than her cheeks. She dropped to her knees in front of Hailey, easing her into laying back against the couch, pulling her panties aside, and I couldn't help but stare. My own daughter's tiny, pink little cunny, stretched so wide around that thick, invading toy! Andi glanced up at me, licking her lips, and ever so slowly began pulling it out. Vicki hadn't been kidding, when she'd ordered Hailey to use her biggest! I'd bought her one, ages ago... I thought it was the responsible thing to do, rather than having her experimenting with who-knew-what she could find around the house. But I definitely hadn't bought her this one! Bloody hell... it was nearly as big as I was! Way too much for a tiny little thing like her, no wonder she'd been wincing so much as she came back down the stairs with it inside! Of course... her mother and aunt hadn't been any bigger than she was, and they'd both managed to take me just fine... but that was something I couldn't let myself think about! Nor about how smooth, pink and aroused she was, her beautiful little clitty standing so rigidly at attention... and definitely not about what a huge, creamy mess she'd made on her toy!
Andi took the toy, and eagerly started to lick, staring me straight in my eyes as she did it. To lick... and then to suck. And before long, to tilt her head back, and slide it all the way down her throat! Now that... that was something neither Jeannie nor Sarah had ever been able to do! She pulled it back out again, slowly, smacking her lips in obvious enjoyment at the taste of my daughter's pussy. Then she moved back to the center of the circle, a little bit behind where Vicki was, getting down onto her knees, easing it into place, moaning and trembling as she eased herself down. She leaned forward just a little, supporting herself with her palms flat on the floor, her upper arms squishing together those huge, gravity-defying tits, as she started to bounce.
Lin returned, whimpering with the pain of the binder clips she'd found. Not just on her nipples, as she'd been told to do, but on her clitty, too! God, that must hurt! She climbed gingerly back into her seat, up on her feet this time, with her knees spread wide so I'd be able to see. And she began flicking at her clips with her fingers, making herself gasp and moan!
Then it was Hailey's turn again. She picked up the bottle, prepared to spin it... and set it down again, pointing straight at me.
“Hailey...”
“Dare... Daddy,” she purred. She hadn't called me 'daddy' in years, not since she'd been a little girl... and she'd certainly never done it while seductively biting her lip at me! “Tell me what you want me to do!”
“I...” I swallowed. I knew I shouldn't, but... “Strip for me, baby! Strip for me, kiss me, and show me how you make yourself cum, while I play with that pretty little ass!”
“You really think it's pretty, Daddy?” she giggled, blushing adorably.
“Fuck, yes!” I moaned. Vicki was getting more aggressive now, sucking hungrily, stroking me and playing with my balls, and I reached down to lovingly stroke my fingers through her soft blonde hair. Hailey quickly stripped off, her lips meeting mine in a deep, passionate kiss, my arm wrapping around her, the unexpected tightness of my grip on her ass making her squeak adorably as I pulled her tighter against my side. Her hand reaching down, and she moaned into my lips as she began masturbating herself for me.
“Oh! Oh God! Oh I'm cumming, Daddy! I'm cumming for you!” I turned from my daughter's kiss, staring deeply into Erica's eyes as she came. It obviously took a lot out of her, leaving her slow and uncoordinated as she stripped herself of the rest of her clothes, clumsily crawling in on my other side, cuddling and taking turns with Hailey kissing me.
“Oh, yes sweetie! Just like that! Oh, Vicki, baby... you're going to make Daddy cum!” I moaned. She started sucking even harder, and I broke off kissing so I could stare into those big, beautiful blue eyes as it happened. She choked a little—not unexpected, for her first time ever—but she definitely enjoyed the feeling of me bursting into her mouth, I could tell by the way she was moaning around my shaft! She swallowed every drop, too, which surprised me. It actually turned into a point of contention; the other four had wanted a chance to share! But they eventually agreed that since it had been her first, she was entitled to be a little bit selfish about it—just this once!
“Spin the bottle again, Daddy?” Hailey purred against my lips. “I know you need time to recover... but once you have, the bottle's the only fair way to decide which of us you're going to fuck first!”
Had they been planning this from the start? I wouldn't put it past the little minxes. We moved the couches and chairs further back out of our way, and covered the floor with opened sleeping bags and blankets.
Lin was first, and she got exactly what she wanted; the other four held her down for me, and no amount of screaming, crying, or begging was ever going to make me stop! I cuddled her tightly to my chest after I finished in her, waiting for her tears to fade, and she thanked me with a deep, passionate kiss, swearing up and down that it had been even better than she'd always imagined it would be.
Vicki was next, and I was hesitant about that. But I took her into the other room, to talk to her out of earshot of the other girls, and she assured me it really was what she wanted. I took her virginity in a slow, gentle missionary love-making, kissing and cuddling her throughout.
Erica took me aside as well, when it was her turn. She wanted to apologize; she still wanted to give me her ass, she said, but some other night, when we could be alone. She was too nervous that she wouldn't be able to make it fit on her first time trying, and she didn't want the others to see her fail. It took some doing, to reassure her that I really didn't mind, and there was nothing she needed to apologize for. Once she finally started to believe me, she asked if she could show me something on her phone. It surprised me... but I agreed that I was willing; I bound her wrists with rope and tied it to a beam in the ceiling, fucking her hard from behind, spanking her ass, pulling on her nipples, and roughly slapping her tits! And yes, reaching around her to play with her clitty piercing, too; I'd never been with a girl who had one of those before—of course I couldn't resist!
Andi had taken what I'd said about my favourite positions very much to heart; she rode me in cowgirl, letting me squeeze and play with those phenomenal tits of hers as much as I liked! But then, when I could tell she was starting to get tired, she absolutely refused to stop! Even when her thighs were shaking, the tears flowing liberally down her cheeks from the sensitivity her multiple orgasms were making her feel, still she insisted on doing it all herself, determined not to stop, or even to change positions, until she'd earned my cum all on her own! And she did it, too! God knows how she found the endurance... but she did. And as she was laying on my chest, panting to recover her breath, she whispered into my ear, shyly promising me she'd get better at it with practice. God... I didn't see how that would even be possible, and I told her as much! She giggled shyly at the praise, and we started to kiss, softly, lovingly, until I softened enough to fall out.
Last... was Hailey. My own sweet, beautiful, perfect daughter Hailey. I still wasn't sure if she'd somehow worked it out to go last, or if it had just happened that way. I suspected the former. But it wasn't out of a lack of eagerness, that was for sure! She sat me down on the couch, and crawled into my lap straddling my hips. She rode me slow and gentle, my hands on her cute little ass helping lift her up and down my shaft, her arms wrapped tightly around the back of my neck as we made out.
I could hardly believe I'd done it. It took me long into the night, but by the time we finally collapsed together into a big, sweaty cuddle-pile to fall asleep, I'd filled all five of their hot little pussies with my cum. We'd already decided; the girls were going to wait until morning first, then they were going to text their parents that the birthday party was being extended, and they wouldn't be getting home until late Sunday night. After that... well, we'd see. We'd have to wait until they graduated high school, before we could have them move in for real. I don't think Hailey was in any particular rush; she was already teasing the others that she'd be getting me all to herself on any night they weren't around!
As I felt myself nodding off to sleep, surrounded on all sides by hot, soft flesh, I was already dreaming about tomorrow. I wasn't sure if I was really going to be able to match Lin's feat, of being able to cum ten times in a single day, twice each for all five of the amazing, sexy little teenage fuck-dolls I'd just finished claiming as my own...
But damn if I wasn't going to be trying my best, every single day!